Misdiagnosing ADHD and Autism

I have heard public service messages lately regarding autism. The aim is to raise awareness about autism because about one in every 88 children are diagnosed with autism (or autism spectrum disorder), according to recent statistics  released by the CDC. That is also the figure quoted by the Autism Society. Alternately, experts estimate that five percent of school-age children (or 5 in 100) have convergence insufficiency. (The estimates also indicate that 25% of school age children have a vision issue that adversely affects their learning.)  That means that convergence insufficiency is much more prevalent than autism and I have not heard any awareness ads yet! I also haven’t seen any changes in the way we diagnose (or fail to diagnose) vision issues.

Not only are we failing to help children overcome their vision issues, we are also misdiagnosing! An article by Laura Novak in the New York Times dated September 11, 2007 entitled Not Autistic or Hyperactive. Just Seeing Double at Times details the experience of 9-year-old Raea Gragg, who had been diagnosed with ADHD and depression. A behavioral pediatrician treated the symptoms with three drugs. Then a school reading expert suggested she see a behavioral optometrist and she was quickly diagnosed with convergence insufficiency. Here’s part of the NYT article:

“Specialists conducted a battery of tests. The possible diagnoses mounted: autism spectrum disorder, neurofibromatosis, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, anxiety disorder. A behavioral pediatrician prescribed three drugs for attention deficit and depression. The only constant was that Raea, now 9, did anything she could to avoid reading and writing.

Though she had already had two eye exams, finding her vision was 20/20, this year a school reading specialist suggested another. And this time the optometrist did what no one else had: he put his finger on Raea’s nose and moved it in and out. Her eyes jumped all over the place. Within minutes he had the diagnosis: convergence insufficiency, in which the patient sees double because the eyes cannot work together at close range.

Experts estimate that 5 percent of school-age children have convergence insufficiency. They can suffer headaches, dizziness and nausea, which can lead to irritability, low self-esteem and inability to concentrate. Doctors and teachers often attribute the behavior to attention disorders or seek other medical explanations. Mrs. Gragg said her pediatrician had never heard of convergence insufficiency.

Dr. David Granet, a professor of ophthalmology and pediatrics at the University of California, San Diego, said: “Everyone is familiar with A.D.H.D. and A.D.D., but not with eye problems, especially not with convergence insufficiency. But we don’t want to send kids for remedial reading and education efforts if they have an eye problem. This should be part of the protocol for eye doctors.”

In 2005, Dr. Granet studied 266 patients with convergence insufficiency. Nearly 10 percent also had diagnoses of attention deficit or hyperactivity — three times that of the general population. The reverse also proved true: examining the hospital records of 1,700 children with A.D.H.D., Dr. Granet and colleagues found that 16 percent also had convergence insufficiency, three times the normal rate. “When five of the symptoms of A.D.H.D. overlap with C.I.,” he said, “how can you not step back and say, Wait a minute?”

Dr. Eric Borsting, an optometrist and professor at the Southern California College of Optometry who has also studied the links between vision and attention problems, agreed. “We know that kids with C.I. are more likely to have problems like loss of concentration when reading and trouble remembering what they read,” he said. “Doctors should look at it when there’s a history of poor school performance.”

Dr. Stuart Dankner, a pediatric ophthalmologist in Baltimore and an assistant clinical professor at Johns Hopkins, said that children should be tested for convergence difficulty, but cautioned that it was not the cause of most attention and reading problems. Dr. Dankner recommended an overall assessment by a psychologist or education specialist. “An eye exam should be done as an adjunct,” he said, “because even if the child has convergence difficulty, they will usually also have other problems that need to be addressed.”

Doctors recommend a dilated eye exam and a check of eye teaming and focusing skills. Testing includes using a pen or finger to test for the “near point of convergence,” as well as a phoropter, which uses lenses and prisms to test the eyes’ ability to work together.

There is no consensus on how to treat convergence insufficiency. Next spring, the National Eye Institute will announce the results of a $6 million randomized clinical trial measuring the benefits of vision therapy in a doctor’s office versus home-based therapy.

For Raea Gragg, the treatment was relatively simple. For nine months she wore special glasses that use prisms to help the eyes converge inward. She then had three months of vision therapy. She has just entered fourth grade and is reading at grade level. “Raea didn’t know how to describe it because that’s all she’s ever known,” her mother said. “She felt like she had been telling us all along that she couldn’t see, but nobody listened.”

Studies since this article have shown a significant improvement when patients with convergence insufficiency are treated with vision therapy. Since the symptoms overlap so much, we should be screening all children for these vision disorders, particularly the ones who are having trouble in school. And, what constitutes having trouble in school? My son could do the work, but just didn’t want to. I can’t fathom how difficult it may have been for him to complete schoolwork while suffering from convergence insufficiency. What I’m also learning is that teaching the eyes to converge doesn’t automatically provide confidence, drive or good study habits. We’re still working on that part.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s